Administrative non-compliance – and understatement penalties
April 25, 2013
DBV Projek
May 27, 2013

article3blogMany commentators believed that this year’s Budget presented the Minister of Finance with the toughest conditions and very little space to maneuver since the 1997’s.

He was faced with balancing the country’s slowing growth rates and decreasing fiscal revenue with an ever increased demand on public spending.

Not surprisingly, the focus areas in the Budget Speech by our Minister of Finance remained on the protection and enhancement of the tax base, tax incentives for the development of business, and tax avoidance.

We set out below a summary of the most prominent changes:

Personal Taxes

With a sigh of relief for the high-end earners, the widely expected increase in the personal income tax rate from a maximum rate of 40% to the anticipated 42%/43% did not materialize.

The lower to middle- income earners have received relief in the increase of the primary, secondary (applicable to persons 65 years and older) and tertiary (applicable to persons 75 years or older) rebates and the tax thresholds have been adjusted as follows:


  • Primary rebate: Increased from R11 440 – R12 080
  • Secondary rebate: Increased from R6 390 – R6 750
  • Tertiary Rebate: Increased from R2 130 – R2 250

Tax Thresholds

  • Below age of 65 years: R63 556 – R67 111
  • Age 65 years to below 75 years: R99 056 – R104 611
  • Age 75 years and over: R110 889 – R117 111

The Capital Gains tax rate was also not affected and remained the same at an inclusion rate of 33.33% for individuals, resulting in a maximum effective rate of 13.33%.

The tax free interest allowance earned from a South African source by any natural person under the age of 65 years, has been increased from R22 800 to R23 800 per annum, and persons 65 years and older, has increased from R33 000 to R34 500 per annum. This will most likely remain constant in the years to come, given the introduction of the savings and investment initiatives.

Monthly tax credits for medical scheme contributions will be increased from R230 to R242 for the first two beneficiaries and from R154 to R162 for each additional beneficiary, with effect from 1 March 2013.

As to retirement, the tax treatment of pension, provident and retirement annuity funds will be simplified and harmonized allowing provident fund members to receive a tax deduction on their own contributions. More competition is promoted by allowing providers other than life officers to sell living annuities.

From an effective date on or after 2015 (called “T-day” in Treasury’s Retirement Reform Proposals for further consultation dated 27 February 2013), employer contributions to retirement funds on behalf of an employee will become a fringe benefit in the hands of the employees for tax purposes, and the overall permissible deductible contribution rate will be pegged at 27.5% of the greater of remuneration and taxable income, to which an annual cap on deductible contributions of R350 000 will apply. This will apply to all individuals regardless of age.

Last year’s budget introduced the idea of savings and investment initiatives for individuals to encourage the nation to save – we can expect these tax preferred savings and investment vehicles to be introduced from April 2015. This savings account will have an initial annual contribution limit of R30 000 and a lifetime limit of R500 000, which will be increased regularly in line with inflation.

The estate duty rate has remained unchanged at a rate of 20% on the value of an estate exceeding R3.5 million.

Donations tax has also remained unchanged at a rate of 20% and the exempt amount for donations tax purposes remained R100 000 per annum per individual.

Dividends Withholding tax has remained unchanged at a rate of 15%.


The Income tax rate applicable to companies remains unchanged at 28%. The inclusion rate for capital gains tax purposes also remain unchanged at a rate of 66.67%, with an effective rate of 18.66%.

A special dispensation is proposed to ensure uniform tax treatment with regards to employment share schemes, which are in certain circumstances used as a tool to lower overall tax rates for executives and other high- income earners, and schemes that are used for lower income earners but which sometimes result in double-taxation for them.


The comments that the Minister made with regards to trusts, especially the proposals around the so-called new tax regime has created an overnight uproar rooted in uncertainty as to the future of trusts. It is important to note that these are merely proposals at this stage and that the legislation underpinning these proposals and implementation thereof are still to be enacted. The new legislation will be made available for public comment prior to implementation. It is important to bear in mind that the taxation of trusts are to be reviewed, which does not mean that their benefits will be erased in a single action by Treasury.

It is our view that trusts created for legitimate estate planning purposes will remain a powerful estate planning vehicle – the very core of the trust mechanism is and was never the evasion of tax, but the protection of assets.

Exchange Control:

In line with expectations, there was no further relaxation in Exchange Control Regulations for individuals or trusts. This is in light of the previous significant concessions that we have seen in 2010 and 2011.

Voluntary Disclosure Program:

The permanent voluntary disclosure program which came into effect from 1 October 2012 remains intact and taxpayers can still make use of this program to regularise their tax affairs.


As expected, VAT rates remained the same.

Transfer Duty:

As anticipated, transfer duty rates remained unchanged.

Sin taxes:

An increase in the excise duties on alcohol products and tobacco products of between 5.7% and 10% was announced.

Gambling taxes:

A national gambling tax was proposed in 2011. The legislation regulating this will be implemented towards the end of 2013 and tax will apply at a rate of 1% on the gross gambling revenue in addition to provincial rates.


Previously donations made to Section 18A approved charitable institutions were limited to 10% of taxable income in the year of donation and any excess amount could not be carried forward. According to Government this discourages large donations which can be detrimental to the upliftment of the South African social community in need of these donations. It is therefore proposed that donations in excess of 10% of taxable income can now be rolled over as allowable deductions in subsequent years.

Fuel levies

We will see an overall increase of 23 cents per liter in fuel levies from effect 3 April 2013, which includes 8 cents per liter for the Road Accident Fund Levy.


Taxpayers with foreign income:

South African residents are generally subject to worldwide tax, except for income arising from services rendered abroad and where a person spends 183 days or more in any 12 month period outside South Africa. The proposals seem to suggest that income from such services should be brought into the South African worldwide tax net, but subject to appropriate tax credits, especially if a South African employer is involved.

Taxpayers with foreign pensions:

Many South African residents who are working or have worked abroad and foreign residents working in South Africa regularly contribute to local and foreign pension funds, which gives rise to a variety of tax issues. In most instances foreign pensions paid to South African residents are exempt from South African taxation in terms of established legislation, however many issues remain unclear and even the most recent legislation governing foreign pensions are not totally clear.

Given that an overall retirement reform is in place, the fact that cross-border pension issues will also be addressed is welcomed. This will hopefully give more clarity as to whether the source of taxation should be where the services were rendered in relation to the pension income, or where the pension fund making the payment is located. In addition, the reform will also address the existing anomalies in relation to annuity payments and lump sum payments. It is very encouraging that a wide public consultation process will be followed on these issues given its complexity.

Aggressive tax planning, tax avoidance and erosion of the tax base:

Companies that have their base of operations in SA but appear to have shifted a large proportion of their profits to low tax jurisdictions where only a few people are employed, will come under severe scrutiny by SARS. SARS is aggressively pursuing schemes identified under the revised general anti- avoidance rules and have done their homework and now have various tax information sharing and exchange agreements in place to track transactions through multiple jurisdictions and entities.

Base erosion and profit shifting were identified as major problems and South Africa is participating in the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development’s (“OECD”) work in this area. South Africa has committed to assist in countering abusive tax avoidance, as well as the abuse of tax treaty benefits, incomplete disclosure and fraudulent claims and will continue with efforts to put a stop to aggressive tax planning, base erosion and profit shifting.

Although comments have been made that anomalies will be removed in the current Controlled Foreign Company regime, the above would seem to indicate that these rules would equally be strengthened or new rules introduced to combat tax leakage where the current rules, especially the use of Foreign Business Establishments, are abused. This seems to be emphasised by the following extract from the Budget Speech:

“The South African Revenue Services is currently engaging with companies that have their base of operations in SA but appear to have shifted a large proportion of their profits to low tax jurisdictions where only a few people are employed. This is unacceptable!”

Offshore trusts and foundations:

Offshore trusts were also identified in line with local trusts and the comments made regarding the review of the taxation of trusts would equally apply to offshore trusts.

Offshore foundations have received special attention and any distributions made by offshore foundations would be treated as ordinary income in future.


Although most taxpayers will give a sigh of relief, those who are non-compliant or lurking in the dark, should take note as the shortfall may very well come from your pocket. Now more than ever, specialist advice is no longer a luxury but a necessity!

This article is a general information sheet and should not be used or relied on as professional advice. No liability can be accepted for any errors or omissions nor for any loss or damage arising from reliance upon any information herein. Always contact your financial adviser for specific and detailed advice.

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse, you agree to our use of cookies